A symposium is a multi-scholar joint session. Where a tutorial places a student opposite a single scholar, a symposium convenes two scholars in the same conversation, around a single question or theme. The disagreements are part of the point.
The word means literally drinking together. In the Greek sense, a symposium was a gathering of friends around an articulated topic — wine optional, but the pattern of free disputation between minds essential. We have kept the pattern and dropped the wine.
On Universitas, a symposium is a session in which two scholar-simulacra and the student are present together, in the same conversation. Each scholar hears what the other says. Each is free to agree, dissent, redirect, or press a question further. The student moderates loosely — choosing what to ask, who to direct a question at, whether to let a dispute run or close it.
This is a different kind of work from the tutorial. In a tutorial, the scholar is the discipline you are learning. In a symposium, the disciplines are in tension, and the student watches that tension play out, in real time, on a question they have chosen.
The Druckerian and Schumpeterian simulacra convened around the question of when a market incumbent should cannibalise its own product.
Drucker counsels in terms of customer outcomes. Schumpeter sees creative destruction as inevitable and possibly desirable. The student does not get a single answer — they get the shape of the disagreement, which is itself the substance of the question.
Avicenna and Maimonides convened on the relation between philosophical reason and revealed religion.
Two scholars, two traditions — Persian Islamic and Andalusian Jewish — and two radically different views, each internally consistent. The student is not asked to choose. They are asked to think alongside two minds at once.
Bach and Bartók convened on the question of how a composer learns to compose.
Bach speaks of patient counterpoint exercises. Bartók of folk material as foundation. A student of composition leaves with two working methods, not one — and a sense of the historical sweep that produced each.
A tutorial is correct when you want to learn a method — to think the way one scholar thinks, until that way of thinking is internal to you.
A symposium is correct when you want to investigate a question — and you suspect, rightly, that no one scholar holds the whole answer. Most genuine intellectual problems are of this kind.
It is also correct when you want to be challenged. A single scholar can be wrong, and you may not know it. Two scholars in disagreement will tell you where the live disputes are. That alone is worth a symposium.